Choosing roofing materials for Colorado Springs
Hail, snow, sun and wind narrow the field. Here is how the common choices compare in this climate.
The main options compared
| Material | Hail | Snow | Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Architectural asphalt | Bruises in larger hail | Fine with ice and water shield | Lowest |
| Class 4 impact-rated asphalt | Highest rating on UL 2218 | Fine with ice and water shield | Moderate |
| Standing-seam steel | May dent cosmetically, rarely leaks | Sheds well; needs snow guards | High |
| Stone-coated steel | Textured finish hides dents | Sheds reasonably | High |
| TPO or EPDM membrane | Low-slope roofs only | Needs good drainage | Varies |
Architectural shingles
The default on most homes here. Thicker and more wind-resistant than old three-tab shingles, and the least expensive option. They are also the most likely to need replacing after a big hail year.
Class 4 impact-rated shingles
Built to flex rather than crack under a hailstone. For homes that have already had one hail roof, these are usually our first suggestion.
Metal
Standing seam suits mountain and foothill homes, sheds snow and does not burn. Stone-coated steel looks more like shingles or shakes and hides dents. Both cost considerably more up front; see the metal cost guide.
A word on colour and heat
Lighter colours reflect more summer sun, though at this altitude the bigger concern is ultraviolet, which ages every colour. Pick a colour you like and that your HOA allows; ventilation does more for attic heat than shingle colour.
Quick answers
Do I need HOA approval for a new material or colour?
Often, yes. Many Colorado Springs subdivisions have architectural committees. Check before you order.
Is tile used here?
Rarely. It is heavy, and freeze-thaw and hail make it a hard fit for this climate.